FINDING ALTERNATIVES TO
PERSISTENT ORGANIC POLLUTANTS (POPs)
FOR TERMITE MANAGEMENT
Back to Table of Contents
TABLE 1. Availability of Alternative Termite Management Strategies to POPs for Subterranean, Arboreal and Drywood Termites.
|
Management Strategy |
Termite Type by Nesting |
Time of Application of Management Strategy |
|||
|
|
Subterranean |
Arboreal Nesters and Subterranean Aerial |
Drywood |
Pre-/During Construction |
Post- Construction |
|
Building Design & Site Preparation |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes (best) |
Yes (repairs) |
|
Termite Resistant Construction and use of Preservative-treated Timber Products |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes (best) |
Yes (repairs) |
|
Physical Barriers |
Yes |
Yes, but limited |
Yes |
Yes (best) |
Yes (repairs) |
|
Termiticides to soil and topical and subsurface applications to wood. |
Yes |
Yes, but limited |
Yes |
Yes (best) |
Yes |
|
Baiting Systems |
Yes |
(insufficient data available for arboreal nesters) |
No |
No |
Yes |
|
Space Fumigation |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
|
Thermal Control |
No |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
|
Biological Control |
Experimental |
Experimental |
No |
No |
Yes |
Determination of the termite pest (subterranean, arboreal
or drywood) is necessary before proceeding with the information in this
table.
Many of the management methods mentioned may not be commercially
available for your country/locality, and effectiveness
and safety information
may not be available.
TABLE 2. Termite Management POPs Alternative: Building Design and Site Preparation
|
Requirement |
Activity |
Considerations |
|
|
|
|
|
Building Design (in reference to termite prevention) |
Choice of building materials |
Soil contact and whether physical or chemical barriers will be used beneath the building material. |
|
|
Ease of inspection of structural components |
Concrete slab edge exposure; removable skirting boards |
|
|
|
|
|
Building Site Preparation |
Remove obvious nests of pest species of termite from site |
Difficult to accomplish and can be expensive, but best for long-term prevention. |
|
|
Remove tree stumps and logs and prune vegetation in and around building site. |
Difficult to accomplish and can be expensive, but best for long-term prevention. |
|
|
Remove all construction and building debris from the building site |
Doable and should be done for all new construction sites. |
|
|
Consider water drainage at site. |
Fill or grade around building. Adding gutters for appropriate drainage away from building. |
|
|
Landscape with termite resistant materials. |
Limit mulches to thin layers around the outside perimeter of buildings. |
|
Progressive Inspection of Building Work |
Ensure compliance with local building codes and regular termite inspections. |
Inspections by competent, independent personnel |
Determination of the termite
pest (subterranean, arboreal or drywood) is necessary before proceeding
on with the information in
this table. Many of the management methods mentioned may not be
commercially available for
your country/locality and effectiveness and safety information also
may not be available.
TABLE 3. Termite Management POPs Alternative: Termite
Resistant Construction
and
use of
Preservative-treated Timber Products
|
Types |
Specifics/Mode of Action |
Considerations |
|
Masonry |
Clay and concrete bricks, concrete blocks and stone, not a barrier to subterranean attack. |
Termites may be able to penetrate mortar joints or use the hollow areas in the bricks and blocks |
|
Concrete elements |
Not a barrier to subterranean termite attack. |
Produced with certain specifications that vary. Cracks commonly occur allowing termite entry. |
|
Steel, aluminium and other metals |
Exclusion for subterranean termites. |
Limited availability |
|
Naturally resistant timbers |
Toxic/repellent for subterranean, arboreal and drywood termites. |
Limited availability |
|
|
|
|
|
Preservative-treated timbers |
|
|
|
Ammoniacal Copper Quat (ACQ) |
Metabolic poison |
Apply to subterranean, arboreal, and drywood termites. |
|
Chrommated copper arsenate (CCA) |
Metabolic poison |
Apply to subterranean, arboreal, and drywood termites |
|
Copper Naphthenate |
Metabolic poison |
Apply to subterranean, arboreal, and drywood termites |
|
Zinc Napthenate |
Metabolic poison |
Apply to subterranean, arboreal, and drywood termites |
|
Copper Azole |
Metabolic poison |
Little published data. |
|
Creosote Oil |
Metabolic poison |
Being phased out |
|
Disodium Octaborate tetrahydrate (DOT) |
Metabolic poison |
Apply to subterranean, arboreal, and drywood termites |
|
Extract of Azidirachtin |
Repellant, Metabolic poison |
Published information limited. |
|
Neem Oil |
Repellant, Metabolic poison |
Published information limited. |
|
Silica Gel |
Repellant, very toxic metabolic poison |
Environmentally very persistent, being phased out. |
|
Cresote |
Repellant and very toxic metabolic poison |
Being phased out. |
|
Construction practices |
|
|
|
No wood-soil contact |
Exclusion |
Apply to subterranean and arboreal nesters. |
|
Seal foundation cracks |
Exclusion |
Apply to subterranean and arboreal nesters. |
|
Fill hollow-block construction |
Exclusion |
Apply to subterranean and arboreal nesters. |
|
No exterior sliding in soil contact |
Exclusion |
Apply to subterranean and arboreal nesters. |
|
Damaged wood removal |
Exclusion |
Apply to subterranean, arboreal, and drywood termites |
Determination
of the termite pest (subterranean, arboreal or drywood) is necessary before
proceeding on
with the information in this table. Many of the management methods mentioned may
not be commercially
available for your country/locality and effectiveness and safety
information also may not be available.
TABLE 4: Termite Management POPs Alternative: Physical Barriers
|
Active Ingredient |
Mode of Action |
Application/ Considerations |
|
Concrete Slab |
Exclusion |
Has to be produced to certain specifications; joints and penetrations require additional protective measures. Wide range of materials and systems used, see below. |
|
Graded Particles |
||
|
Sand |
Exclusion |
These barriers can be breached and bridged over by foraging mud tunnels. |
|
crushed rock, granites and basalts |
Exclusion |
These barriers can be breached and bridged over by foraging mud tunnels. |
|
Glass |
Exclusion |
These barriers can be breached and bridged over by foraging mud tunnels. |
|
Solid Sheet Material |
||
|
high grade stainless steel |
Exclusion |
These barriers can be breached and bridged over by foraging mud tunnels. |
|
marine grade aluminium |
Exclusion |
These barriers can be breached and bridged over by foraging mud tunnels. |
|
certain plastics |
Exclusion |
These barriers can be breached and bridged over by foraging mud tunnels. |
|
Woven Stainless Steel Mesh |
||
|
high grade stainless steel |
Exclusion |
These barriers can be breached and bridged over by foraging mud tunnels. |
Determination
of the termite pest (subterranean, arboreal or drywood) is necessary before
proceeding on with
the information in this table. All physical barriers in this table apply
tosubterranean termites. The above barriers
do not apply to drywood termites. Many
of the management methods mentioned may not be commercially
available for your country/locality and effectiveness and safety information
also may not be available.
TABLE 5. Termite Management POPs Alternative: Termiticides in Soil or Other Carriers
|
Active Ingredient |
Mode of Action |
Application/Considerations |
|
Chemical Applied to Soil or Foam |
||
|
|
|
|
|
Repellant |
|
|
|
Bifenthrin |
Repellant and toxic, sodium ion channel inhibitor |
Applied as sprays or via reticulation systems (enclosed tubing). Termites can detect chemical and move from treated areas. Lethal effects are not passed among colony members. |
|
Cyfluthrin |
Repellant and toxic, sodium ion channel inhibitor |
|
|
Cypernethrin |
Repellant and toxic, sodium ion channel inhibitor |
|
|
Fenitrothion |
Toxicant, cholinesterase inhibitor |
|
|
Fenvalerate |
Repellant and toxic, sodium ion channel inhibitor |
|
|
Phenthioate |
Toxicant, cholinesterase inhibitor |
|
|
Permethrin |
Repellant and toxic, sodium ion channel inhibitor |
|
|
Silafluofen |
Repellant and toxic, sodium ion channel inhibitor |
|
|
Triazophos |
Toxicant, cholinesterase inhibitor |
|
|
Tralomethrin |
Repellant and toxic, sodium ion channel inhibitor |
|
|
Zeta-cypermethrin |
Repellant and toxic, sodium ion channel inhibitor |
|
|
Nonrepellant |
|
|
|
Chlorpyrifos |
Toxicant, cholinesterase inhibitor |
Application as above. Termites unable to detect chemical. Lethal effects are delayed and may be passed among colony members.
|
|
Imidacloprid |
Toxicant, non-repllent; nicotinamide inhibitor |
|
|
Fipronil |
Toxicant, non-repellent; GABA inhibitor |
|
|
Chlorphenapyr |
Toxicant |
|
|
Thiome |
Toxicant |
|
|
Chemicals Applied as foams to soil or wood. |
Many of the same active ingredients mentioned above. |
Apply to subterranean, arboreal nesters, and drywood termites |
|
Chemicals Applied as Synthetic Fibre Matting or Plastic Laminate Sheets |
|
|
|
Deltamethrin |
Repellant and toxic, sodium ion channel inhibitor |
Acts as more chemical than physical barrier. Apply to subterranean termites. |
Determination
of the termite pest (subterranean, arboreal or drywood) is necessary before
proceeding on
with the information in this table. Soil treatments can be breached and bridged
over by
subterranean
termite foraging mud tunnels. For drywood termites, the toxixant
must be applied to
tunnels used by
foragers to be effective; if missed, the termites will not die. Many of the
management methods mentioned
may not be commercially available for your country/locality and effectiveness and safety information
also may not be
available.
TABLE 6. Termite Management POPs Alternative: Bait technology
|
Active Ingredient |
Mode of Action |
Application/ Considerations |
|
Diflubenzuron |
Chitin synthesis inhibitor |
In food matrix |
|
Chlorflurazuron |
Chitin synthesis inhibitor |
In food matrix |
|
Hexaflumuron |
Chitin synthesis inhibitor |
In food matrix |
|
Triflumuron |
Chitin synthesis inhibitor |
Dust |
|
Disodium octoborate tetrahydrate |
Metabolic toxin |
In food matrix/dust |
|
Arsenic trioxide |
Metabolic toxin |
Dust |
|
Hydramethylnon |
Metabolic inhibitor |
In food matrix |
|
Sulfluramid |
Metabolic Inhibitor |
In food matrix |
|
|
|
|
|
Biocontrol Agents |
|
|
|
Fungus: spores, mycelium. |
Grows through cuticle and utilizes entire termite body |
Also biocontrol system (see Table 9). Use as bait and soil treatment is experimental. |
|
Nematodes: infective stages |
Invade; carry bacterium which produces lethal toxins |
Bait system is experimental |
Determination of the termite
pest (subterranean, arboreal or drywood) is necessary before proceeding on with
the information in
this table. There are no commercially available baits for drywood termites. Many of the
management methods mentioned may not be commercially available for your country/locality and
effectiveness
and safety information also may not be available.
TABLE
7. Termite Management POPs Alternative: Fumigants
(This
strategy is employed to deal with drywood termites, aerial colonies of subterranean termites
and cases where arboreal species nest inside structures.)
|
Active Ingredient |
Mode of Action |
Application/ Considerations |
|
Carbon Dioxide |
Asphyxiant |
All of these gases are very toxic and require evacuation of structure prior to treatment. |
|
Methyl bromide |
Metabolic poison |
|
|
Phosphine |
Metabolic poison |
|
|
Sulfuryl fluoride |
Metabolic poison |
Determination
of the termite pest (subterranean, arboreal or drywood) is necessary before
proceeding on
with
the information in this table. Many of the management methods mentioned may
not be commercially
available for your country/locality and effectiveness
and safety information also may not be available.
TABLE 8.
Termite Management POPs Alternative: Thermal Treatment.
(Apply mostly to drywood and
arboreal nesting termites.)
|
Active Ingredient |
Mode of Action |
Application/ Considerations |
|
Electricity |
Electric shock is best guess. |
All have limited effectiveness and safety data and also limited in use. |
|
Heat |
Denature proteins using high temperatures via propane heaters. |
|
|
Liquid Nitrogen |
Disruption of cellular membranes using very low temperatures. |
|
|
Microwave |
Denature proteins using high temperatures via microwaves. |
Determination of the termite
pest (subterranean, arboreal or drywood) is necessary before proceeding on with
the information in
this table. Many of the management methods mentioned may not be commercially
available for
your country/locality and effectiveness and safety information also may not be available.
TABLE
9. Termite Management POPs Alternative: Biocontrol
(Apply mostly to subterranean
and arboreal nesting termites.)
|
Active Ingredient |
Mode of Action |
Application/ Considerations |
|
Fungus: spores, mycelium. |
Grows through cuticle and utilize entire termite body |
Bait systems (see Table 6); soil treatments; experimental and limited commercial |
|
Nematodes: infective stages |
Invade; carry bacterium which produces lethal toxins |
Bait systems; experimental |
|
Ants |
Predator |
Opportunistic; not suitable for targeted applications |
Determination of the termite
pest (subterranean, arboreal or drywood) is necessary before proceeding on with
the information in
this table. Many of the management methods mentioned may not be commercially available
for
your country/locality and effectiveness and safety information also may not be available.
TABLE 10. Crops Attacked by Termites
|
Crop |
Country |
|
A. ANNUAL CROPS |
|
|
1. Cereals Maize
Sorghum Rice Barley Millet Wheat
|
Argentina, Benin, Brazil, Democratic Republic of Congo, Ethiopia, India, Kenya, Malawi, Nigeria, Paraguay, South Africa, Saudi Arabian Peninsula, Swaziland, Tanzania, Uganda, Uruguay, Zambia, Zimbabwe, Yemen Ethiopia, India, Malawi Argentina, Brazil, India, Paraguay, Uruguay India China, Ethiopia, India, Yemen India, Yemen |
|
2. Pulse crops Beans Cowpea Pigeon pea [= chich pea??] |
India, Malawi India, Malawi India [Chick pea], Malawi
|
|
3. Oil crops Groundnut
Sunflower Soybean
|
Australia, Botswana, Brazil, Burkina Faso, China, Ethiopia, Gambia, Guyana, India, Malawi, Mali, Niger, Nigeria, Senegal, Sudan, Zambia, Zimbabwe India, Yemen India, Brazil, Guyana |
|
4. Sugarcane |
Argentina, Australia, Bolivia, Brazil, Caribbean, Central Africa Republic, China, Colombia, Cuba, Dominican Republic, Guyana, India, Jamaica, Kenya, Mexico, Nicaragua, Nigeria, Pakistan, Panama, Paraguay, Philippines, Uruguay, Somalia, South Africa, Sudan, Venezuela |
|
5. Root crops Sweet potatoes Potatoes Yam Cassava
|
India, Jamaica Australia, India Ghana, Nigeria Brazil, Guyana, West Africa, Malawi
|
|
6. Vegetables Tomato Okra Pepper Egg plant Cabbage
|
Saudi Arabian Peninsula, Yemen Saudi Arabian Peninsula, Yemen Saudi Arabian Peninsula, Yemen Saudi Arabian Peninsula India
|
|
B. PERENNIAL CROPS |
|
|
1. Fruit trees Guava Tea Coffee Citrus
Cocoa Passion fruit Banana Mango Papaya Grapes |
India, Saudi Arabian Peninsula India, Malawi, Pakistan, Peru Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia, Kenya Afghanistan, Algeria, Australia, Egypt, India, Iran, Iraq, Israel
Ghana Colombia, Trinidad, Venezuela Malawi Australia, India, Saudi Arabian Peninsula Saudi Arabian Peninsula Australia, India
|
|
2. Palm trees
Oil palml
Date palm
Coconut
|
Ghana, Nigeria, South Asia, Pacific Island
Afghanistan, Algeria, Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Israel, Jordan, Libya, Morocco, Sudan, Tunisia
India, Malaysia, Nigeria, some South Pacific Island |
|
3. Field crop
Pineapple
Cotton |
Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Kenya, Paraguay, Uruguay
Central Africa Republic, India, Malawi, Sudan, Tanzania, Uganda, Yemen |
|
4. Forestry plantations
Rubber Trees
Pine plantations
Hardwood plantations |
Southeast Asia
Australia, Southeast Asia
Mahogany in south Pacific islands, Eucalyptus South America, street trees France, |